What to Look Out For When Buying Diamonds Online?

where and how to buy diamonds?

Which Is The Best Online Vendor?

Unquestionably, e-commerce has become ubiquitous in our lives. Most of us are accustomed to buying everything online. From pizzas, new laptops, clothing and even groceries, I’m sure you probably had bought something online before. However, when it comes to larger expenses, most people still have a slight skepticism towards spending money online.

Just like how buying a new car online doesn’t make you feel comfortable, buying jewelry is also probably going sound weird at first. If you do a simple search on Google, you will probably find a myriad of websites offering their wares at various prices. While most of the websites are serious and legitimate businesses, there do exist a minority of unethical people who could be scammers trying to trick you.

The important question now becomes: how do you choose between which vendors to go with? Well, there are a few key features that can help you differentiate between these sites. And the best of it all, we had also done the legwork and put the vendors to the test.

Do You Get What You See From an Online Diamond Store?

Anyone can download stock photos of different diamonds and put them online. Also, anyone can upload CAD (computer-aided design) drawings of different jewelry artwork and claimed that they made the design. What you should expect from an online diamond distributor is the willingness to share information and data with you.

For example, a series of actual photographs of the stone you are about to buy, videos capturing the performance of the diamond in different lighting or even essential information like grading reports should be made readily available to you.

When buying online, you should also do your own due diligence when sizing up a potential purchase. For example, you could start by comparing the stone’s image with deep zooming or virtual loupes against the grading report. Doing so can help you verify the genuineness of the photographs/videos provided. Needless to say, this is a practice you should bring to your local jeweler too if you intend to shop offline.

snapshot video offers you the ability to see and inspect diamonds upclose with their revolutionary video technology. Check them out now!

Who Will Help You Understand What You Are Buying?

Another aspect of good e-stores is whether or not they provide good customer service. Buying diamonds is usually heavy on your wallet and the industry is full of technical jargon that can easily confuse someone new. So, it’s normal to expect and ask for a live voice or messaging system that will help you clarify any questions you might have.

In fact, you could test a sales person’s product knowledge by asking them a few simple questions: “How can I tell that the diamond I am looking at matches the descriptions in the lab report?” or “Are all GIA triple excellent diamonds the same?” If the answer is to trust them on their word or that all GIA triple excellent stones are the same, you should probably look for another vendor.

Another question can go like this: “What’s the difference between EGL and GIA certifications?” If the jeweler tells you they are of the same standard and tries to push for an EGL stone, you will know he/she isn’t being honest with you. Of course, you probably need to ask other questions pertaining to cut or doubts you have and see how they respond to your queries.

A Huge Assortment – And Very Good Searching Features

choosing a great diamond online

How to Select the Best?

One of the biggest advantages online distributors have over physical stores is the immense inventory size and product range they can offer. In contrast, the assortment a local store can offer might be limited to what the local market is interested in buying.

On this note, if you feel you need something rather exquisite, an online store should usually be able to provide more options and meet your needs easily as compared to a traditional brick and mortar store.

Due to the amount of choices and options available, the usability of the website becomes a priority since making a selection out of tens of thousands of products might be daunting. E-commerce services with categorized search criteria and neat layouts will help you narrow your selections in an organized manner.

One Great Advantage That Really Matters

All of the requirements mentioned above may seem like bare replacements for features the majority of “offline” stores have to offer. However, the truth is far from that. Great photography and videos are very useful and more important than you think it is.

Now, I’m sure you have all heard what the local jewelers had been saying in defense of shopping online: “Nothing beats seeing the stones in reality.” Well, let me rephrase the question and turn it around to you. If you were given 2 diamonds to examine in the store, do you know which to pick or what to look out for?

Most consumers can’t and don’t understand diamonds sufficiently enough to make a smart decision. In fact, you would more likely be able to make a rational decision when there’s no one pressurizing you into a sale compared to having a salesperson talking non-stop beside you.

pave rope diamond ring setting

Explore hundreds of beautifully crafted ring designs in 360° videos at

Of course, you could argue that most physical stores will probably have a “qualified professional” who can help you find what you want and explain why you want to choose a particular diamond or setting design. If you want to have a great variety of options, you can still drive to, say, New York and find a huge store that has a wide range of products where you can get ideas from. Needless, these are all features you have to pay for and the prices in a physical store (usually double of online prices) are indicative of it.

My question to you is: Do you really need to do that in today’s modern age? You can get the same kind of experience via online shopping too. In contrast to local stores, online jewelry vendors are required to offer all the above-mentioned features and more if they want to survive in this competitive market. That is the change we are seeing in today’s online businesses and consumers are the ones who benefit the most.

Internet vendors have a different business model which is based on the absence of expensive rentals and steep advertising fees. With increasing technology and better broadband speeds, you will be surprised at how advanced the experience of Internet shopping can be. For that reason, a good online diamond jeweler can even offer to design an identical ring replica found in your local store, with significantly lower prices and turnaround time.

The best internet diamond stores like and offer indepth information like magnified videos and tangible light performance data to help you make the best decisions when buying a diamond. Experience them for yourself today!

Indepth Reviews of Online Jewelry Stores And Diamond Dealers:

  • Brian Gavin Diamonds – Super Ideal Diamond Cuts (Highly Recommended)
    Brian Gavin is a man who is held in the highest esteem by the industry. He is one of the pioneers who popularized Hearts And Arrows diamonds which are characteristic for their light performance. If you are looking for top quality stuff, this is the place to do so.
  • James Allen – The Leading Online Jeweler With Real Images And Videos (Highly Recommended) is one of the first online sites to revolutionize the world of buying diamonds over the Internet. With high resolution videos and pictures of diamonds combined with free value-added services like having an in-house gemologist to evaluate your choices, you can shop with a peace of mind.
  • White Flash – AGS Ideal Diamonds And Designer Engagement Rings (Highly Recommended)
    If you are looking for ideal cut rounds or princess diamonds with superlative performance, Whiteflash is definitely a vendor you want to check out. They also offer a vast selection of designer rings and high quality settings to choose from.

  • Abazias – The Self Proclaimed Dealer to Offer You Value for Money
    With a bold claim of offering their inventory to consumers at wholesale prices, Abazias seems to be the perfect website for value hunters. Having tried and reviewed their offerings, we don’t fully agree with them. Find out why…
  • B2CJewels – Lowest Prices For Quality Diamonds is a relatively smaller player in the online industry. While they can’t offer you the best in terms of value added services like examining a diamond in person, they offer one of the lowest prices available anywhere else.
  • Blue Nile – The Largest Online Retailer
    They are one of the biggest names you had probably heard about in the online jewelry business. Bluenile was the pioneer that revolutionized the Internet. In recent years, they had improved on their business model by providing better sales policies and video listings. Find out more details in our review…
  • Brilliant Earth Review – The “Green” Diamond Vendor is like the new kid on the block in the world of online diamond retailing. They market their jewelry heavily as “eco-friendly” and “conflict-free” but how much do those matter in the eyes of the consumer?
  • Cartier Diamond Engagement Rings Review – The Big Red C
    I’m sure the name Cartier is no stranger to you when it comes to branded jewelry. With its bright red ring boxes and corporate colors, Cartier makes a lasting impression on people who had come across the brand.
  • Costco Engagement Rings Review – Deal or No Deal?
    Costco is the wholesale giant that is well known in many parts of the world. Besides selling groceries, Costco offers a wide range of other products and even high-end jewelry. However, is the jewelry sold by Costco any good? We find out in this article…
  • The Diamonds Factory – Quality Diamonds at Factory Prices?
    The Diamonds Factory is an online jeweler that is based in the UK and one of the many frequently found in search engine results. In terms of pricing and value added services for consumers, there are many other better alternatives which fare better. Our verdict is: Skip them and move on.
  • Diamond Harmony – Fine Jewelry At Your Convenience features 1000s of high end jewelry online. Learn more about their business and the value that they can provide to consumers.
  • DiamondsOnWeb – A Newer Establishment in Online Jewelry
    From its name, Diamonds on Web is just what their business is all about; to make diamonds available on the Internet. While they are a decent website and business to deal with, there are tons of other vendors who fare better in terms of policies and value added services.
  • – Your Personal Online Jewelry Store
    Diamonds USA has been offering their service online since 1997. They specialize in engagement rings and wedding bands with a huge array of over 1000 unique designs for you to pick from.
  • Excel Diamonds – Family Grown Jeweler
    Being a family business that focuses on quality and customer experiences, has received numerous positive feedback from their customers. Find out what we think about them…
  • Hearts On Fire Review – The World’s Most Perfect Cut Diamond
    One of the biggest names in the international diamond retail industry is Hearts On Fire. They claim to be the company who has world’s most perfectly cut round brilliant diamonds. Read our insights and experience to find out whether they hold up to the marketing publicity they created.
  • Forevermark Diamonds Review – De Beers Re-Marketed
    Forevermark is a line of jewelry created by the world’s largest diamond cartel, De Beers. Launched in 2008, Forevermark became a global presence after seeing success in the Asian region.
  • Helzberg Diamonds Review – Good or Bad?
    Helzberg Diamonds is a large jewelry chain store with a long history dating back to the early 1900s. The company got its breakthrough and made headlines when Warren Buffet bought them over in 1995. In this writeup, we offer some insights to their products and whether they are worth it or not.
  • Jared The Galleria of Jewelry Review
    Jared is perhaps one of the most recognizable off-mall jewelry retail store. Their targeted clientele are the middle to higher income earners who can afford to spend more on luxury products. In this review, we take a look at the shopping process of buying a diamond ring at Jared’s.
  • Kay Jewelers Review – Does Every Kiss Really Begins at Kay’s?
    Since its foundation in 1916, Kay Jewelers has grown to become one of the biggest specialized retail jewelry company. Besides a huge range of products, Kay also retails wedding rings for couples. Read our review to find out more about them…
  • Leibish Review – Fancy Color Diamond Retailer Who Delivers Quality Jewelry
    Leibish & Co is a renowned jeweler who deals primarily in rare colored diamonds. Whether you are interested in one for investments or for a beautiful piece of jewelry, we reveal why is the place to start looking.
  • Ritani Loose Diamonds And Engagement Rings Review
    Ritani has grown its business rapidly over the years and established themselves as the go-to jeweller for many Americans. In this review of, we reveal some surprising finds.
  • Tiffany Engagement Rings Review – A Look at the Brand Associated With Luxury
    Perhaps the most well-known brand in diamond jewelry, Tiffany and Co, is a household name in America. Have you ever wondered what’s the quality inside the blue box really like? This review will disclose things you probably didn’t know about…
  • Union Diamond – An Array of Choices
    Union Diamond boosts an impressive range of certified diamonds and customized designs for their settings. They tend to offer more shapes (like the trilliant cut) and varieties compared to other similar vendors.
  • Victor Canera Review – High End Bespoke Jewelry And Antique Style Diamond Dealer
    Victor Canera prides himself as a jeweler who offers high quality ring settings and ideal cut diamonds. For consumers who are nit-picky about the workmanship of their jewelry, Victor is the best jeweler to satisfy your needs.
  • Zales Review – Bold Claims of Creating the Most Brilliant Diamond in the World
    One of the largest and most well known jewelry chain in America with close to 700 stores nationwide. How does the quality of their diamond jewelry stand out in lieu of all the marketing hype they create and immerse themselves in?

Brands And Location Reviews

Related Articles

Share This Page on Social Media!


  1. Avatar
    August 6, 2016 at 6:14 am

    Hi Paul,

    Your website really helped me in choosing the right diamond for my girlfriend. If it wasn’t for your love of precious gems there would be a lot more uneducated people in the world buying diamonds. I, myself would be one of them.

    I want to thank you, and please keep up with the great work.


    Michael Hulleza.

  2. Avatar
    September 7, 2016 at 5:50 pm

    Hi – Great website and reviews. By any chance do you have an opinion on A Jaffe settings? I have a 3ct stone from my mother and really like one of their settings. As this is my first time shopping for rings, I don’t know much about any of the designers and want to be sure I am getting quality, a reputable name, and not getting ripped off. Thank you in advance! Lisa & Mike

  3. Avatar
    Paul Gian-
    September 8, 2016 at 1:41 am

    Unfortunately, I have no prior experience with A Jaffe. As far as settings go, you can actually go visit them an inspect some of their available settings to find out how well made they are.

    You can read about the things I look out for here:

  4. Avatar
    September 18, 2016 at 6:20 pm

    Can anybody please let me know any online diamond shopping website in Pakistan ? I have been wondering around a website called but they do not sell diamonds but they did sent me a detailed email with many precious gems at a very reasonable cost

  5. Avatar
    Paul Gian-
    September 19, 2016 at 1:23 am

    If you don’t want to get ripped off, start here:

  6. Avatar
    October 2, 2016 at 8:34 pm

    Hi Paul,

    have you ever reviewed a second-hand diamond website / store? I was curious to see how expensive it would be to buy a second hand diamond.


  7. Avatar
    Paul Gian-
    October 3, 2016 at 4:14 am

    I do have experiences with quite a number of them. NONE sells diamonds that are well cut enough (you can imagine the amount of junk people buy and then try to sell off in the 2nd hand market) and/or reliably graded. eBay and many other auction sites are some examples of the 2nd hand market and these are the sites that I warn readers against.

  8. Avatar
    rebecca newsham-
    May 10, 2017 at 10:16 pm

    what do you know about selecting an antique diamond ring? Am looking at some from Edwardian – Art Deco periods. What do I look for?

  9. Avatar
    Paul Gian-
    May 11, 2017 at 2:22 am

    Find a center stone that’s cut to the old styles like the Old Miner or Old European.

    You can generally go down to lower colors to get the rustic tint of yellow (J-K colors). Victor Canera has some nice workmanship on his rings.

  10. Avatar
    July 5, 2017 at 9:57 pm

    Hi Paul,
    I just wanted to thank you for your help!! My fiance bought an idealscope after learning about it on your website. We used it to review diamonds in NYC’s Diamond District. When we saw a stone we thought looked good, we took some idealscope pictures, and then sent you an email asking to help us validate what we saw. You helped us to identify some pretty severe light leakage – which seemed crazy at first because it was a GIA “Ideal” cut stone!! We wound up finding a GORGEOUS diamond from Whiteflash instead. On July 1st, he proposed and I am SO happy with my gorgeous diamond!! Thank you so much for this site, and your willingness to help!!


  11. Avatar
    July 22, 2017 at 7:53 am

    I found a beautiful 2 carat VVS1 diamond on Brilliance .com and have reviewed the report (EGL unfortunately) and viewed the video and zoomed pictures of the diamond. I just wanted to see if you have any experience with this site as the price seems to be much lower than James Allen, or any of the very popular online retailers. Your help is much appreciated as I am ready to purchase a ring to replace my stolen wedding rings. Thanks!

  12. Avatar
    Paul Gian-
    July 22, 2017 at 1:38 pm

    The reason why it is lower priced is not because of the choice of vendor but because of the unreliable grading report the stone has. If you intend to get an EGL graded diamond, be prepared for a giant rip off and over pay.

  13. Avatar
    Michael R-
    July 27, 2017 at 5:51 pm

    I’ve been looking at buying a pink sapphire engagement ring since my girlfriend prefers them to diamonds as the primary or center stone. Almost decided on one at The Natural Sapphire Company online website, but feeling a bit nervous. Is this company “safe?” What are some good/safe sites to buy gemstone jewelry?

    thank you,
    Michael R

  14. Avatar
    Paul Gian-
    July 28, 2017 at 3:58 am

    I have no prior experience with that company. So, I can’t offer much insights there. James Allen do offer gemstone jewelry and have HD videos of loose stones. You might want to check them out:

    As far as diamonds and jewelry goes, they are a reliable vendor that I had personally tested as did many other readers who bought from them.

  15. Avatar
    September 1, 2017 at 3:28 am

    Your review is very helpful. I have been looking around online for different jewelry websites with my husband as he wants to give me a diamond ring for our 25 year anniversary. He is very sweet and really wants to give me something really nice, but at the same time that the diamond is of good quality. There is one site called that has really decent prices and the Design representative he talked to was very knowledgeable and understood what he wanted for me. We are based in the United Kingdom. We haven’t decided to go with them or another store yet, but definitely will take all your advise into consideration before we make any purchase. Thanks!

  16. Avatar
    October 3, 2017 at 3:30 pm

    Hi Paul,

    Your reviews are very informative and have helped my boyfriend and I gain a ton of confidence in our diamond purchase. After viewing diamonds at various brick and mortar jewelry stores (with aset and ideal scopes in hand), as well as online vendors (all of which you’ve reviewed and were spot on), we ended up getting a gorgeous Crafted by Infinity diamond from High Performance Diamonds, which we had mounted on a custom-designed setting made by an amazing local jeweler. Although the ring is not a surprise, my boyfriend insists that the proposal will be a surprise. Now, our friends are seeking our guidance for their engagement ring, and we referred them to our favorite educational sites and resources, including yours. We also provided them with a detailed spreadsheet we created to objectively compare each diamond in consideration within our budget (mostly from Brian Gavin, James Allen, and High Performance Diamonds). We developed strict criteria per your guidance. I’m just curious if you have ever personally dealt with HPD or reviewed the CBI diamonds, which we think offers not only some of the best and most ideal cut diamonds (with aset and ideal scope images to prove), but also one of the best return and upgrade policies in the industry (also accounted for in our spreadsheet). We haven’t found too many reviews on them from experts such as yourself, to direct our friends to, outside of just sharing our own stellar experience. I’m also curious to know if “custom cut” diamond services offered by Brian Gavin and Good Old Gold, vendors we also considered at the time of our purchase, offer better quality and/or value. Looking forward to your insight. Thanks!

  17. Avatar
    Paul Gian-
    October 3, 2017 at 3:52 pm

    I have yet to review a Crafted by Infinity diamond in person. However, going by their online listings and the data they list, their diamonds look very well cut. I have no prior experience with Good Old Gold. However, with Brian Gavin, the custom cut service is useful especially if you need a particular carat weight/clarity/color specification to be fulfilled. Unknown to many, the cost of doing a custom cut with Brian Gavin is actually the same as buying a loose diamond (with the exception of different policies like depositing money upfront and returns).

  18. Avatar
    December 20, 2017 at 4:51 pm

    Kay jewelers, do you no longer care about your customers? You are stealing from me and damaging my credit for your mistake and each time I reach out to resolve the issue, you transfer me to your new financing company and they can’t resolve old matters from your old one. In a customer that fell through the cracks of your financial switch and in return you are attempting to financially ruin me with my credit. Anyone else feeling abandoned and used by this company?

  19. Avatar
    November 22, 2018 at 7:29 am

    these are good suggestions for diamond rings, I am ready to get engaged with my love lately, and we are choosing the diamond ring.

  20. Avatar
    September 7, 2019 at 7:30 pm

    Very bad treatment, very bad behavior I feel sorry that ordered from this website,( he took my money and didn’t deliver my order. Tried to reach him and still didn’t get my money back.
    I do not trust him and I definitely do not recommend this site to any body. It is a horrible experience.
    They left me no option but to take them to court.

Leave A Comment