Elegant, classic looking emerald cut diamonds.
Back in the Art Deco period, the emerald cut diamond was a popular choice for engagement rings. The cutting style features stacked terraces and large parallel facets which were adapted from cutting techniques developed for emeralds (green gemstones).
Naturally classy and sophisticated in appearance, the scintillation pattern of an emerald cut diamond differs from those found in brilliant cutting styles like the rounds or ovals.
Instead of having tiny sparkles of light emitting from the facets, an emerald cut diamond flashes “on” and “off” due to the nature of the step cut. Combined with its timeless appearance, the unique sparkle factor of emerald cut diamonds is a compelling reason for women to love them.
In this write up, I’m going to show you how to select a beautiful emerald cut diamond that exhibits dramatic flashes of light and is full of brilliance. You are also going to find out the insider tips and the things to look out for to avoid poorly cut diamonds.
I will also reveal the best color/clarity ratings and the ideal proportions to look out for when picking out a diamond. And if you are looking for ideas for a great looking engagement ring setting, I’ve got you covered as well.
Let’s jump right in!
Here is a list of topics we will be covering:
What really makes an emerald cut nice?
Emerald cut diamonds usually take on a rectangular outline and chiseled step cuts with straight linear facets. They also have “blocked corners” to give the outline a distinct classic appearance.
As a result of its step cut and parallel faceting structure, emerald cuts don’t bend or reflect light as much as the round diamonds. Consequently, this leads to a loss in brilliance and scintillation properties which makes the emerald cut very poor at hiding material flaws present in the rough stone.
Also, having a huge table facet is like having a big open window which enables you to peer deep into the diamond’s body. This means that any inclusions, flaws or color nuances are easier to be picked out compared to the round diamonds.
Like other fancy shape diamonds, I want to point out that there are no fixed cut parameters or “magical numbers” that is guaranteed to yield a stunning emerald cut diamond.
The table of ideal proportions below is compiled based on my experience with picking great looking emerald cut diamonds with strong light return and luster. It only should serve as a tool to help you weed out poorly cut diamonds.
|Table %||61% – 68%||59% – 70%||58% – 72%||Outside Ranges|
|Depth %||60% – 65%||57% – 68%||56% – 70%||Outside Ranges|
|Polish/Symmetry||Excellent – Very Good||Good||Outside Ranges|
|Length to Width||1.30 – 1.50||1.20 – 1.60||1.10 – 1.70||Outside Ranges|
|Girdle Thickness||Thin – Slightly Thick||V. Thin – Very Thick||Outside Ranges|
|Culet Size||None||Very Small||Small||Outside Ranges|
* Note: The recommended emerald cut diamond proportions should be used as a reference only.
To make your final selection, you need to base your decisions on a magnified video in neutral, unbiased lighting. It is important that you never buy a diamond based on a grading report alone as the certificate doesn’t reveal shape appeal or optical performance characteristics of the diamond.
I also strongly encourage you to utilize light performance tools like ASET to help you assess cut quality. Shopping online gives you access to this data and allows you to enjoy risk-free shopping policies. It also enables you to make rational choices away from the pressure selling and hassling in a brick and mortar store.
Truly well cut emerald cut diamonds are very hard to find and the proportions above are just a guideline to help you get started with. In order to help you get a better idea of how well cut diamonds look like, check out these two diamonds with very strong light performance.
Using the videos, these diamonds were selected for their scintillation patterning and light return. I also look out for the hall of mirrors effect as well as shape appeal to make the selections.
To be clear, I literally had to review more than 500 diamonds just to pick out these four diamonds. And that’s why I stress the importance of diamond videos in neutral, unbiased environments. Also, you have to go online (instead of b&m stores) to get the depth of inventory to cherry pick from.
Emerald-cuts have big stepped surfaces which can expose even the most minor flaws in the diamond’s body. Due to the nature of their step cutting style, they have less brilliance and scintillation and generally require a higher clarity rating to stay eyeclean.
In general, I would recommend VS2 clarity as the “Goldilocks” rating to get an eyeclean diamond without having to pay the premium for higher clarity grades. But do take note that as you go larger in carat size, you would need a higher clarity grade for the diamond to stay eyeclean.
|Carat Size||Recommended Clarity||Most Affordable Clarity|
|0.5 carat or less||VS2 – FL||SI1|
|0.51 ct – 0.99 ct||VS2 – FL||SI1|
|1.00 ct – 1.99 ct||VS2 – FL||VS2|
|2.00 ct or more||VS1 – FL||VS2|
For those who want to get better value for money, I recommend vendors that feature an HD video and provide magnified images of the diamond listing. This will help you push the envelope for a lower clarity grade without compromising the diamond’s appearance.
Below, I’ve listed two emerald cuts which are 1 carat in size and have a clarity grade of SI1. As you can see, the type and location of inclusions can seriously affect the appearance of the diamond.
Eye-clean SI1 with scattered inclusions
Not eye-clean due to the dark cloud inclusion
Here, I want to highlight that the eyeclean SI1 emerald cut is an outlier because most SI1 diamonds aren’t eyeclean. I was only able to cherry pick this eyeclean SI1 diamond because of the videos and photography listings provided by James Allen.
The bottomline is, you need to exercise caution when you are buying diamonds of a lower clarity grade.
Regardless of where you shop, you need to examine the diamond under magnification in unbiased, neutral lighting. As much as possible, I also recommend inspecting the diamond from as many tilt angles as possible to check it for eyecleanliness.
With their large, open facets, emerald cut diamonds tend to reveal their color easily. However, you should bear in mind that color evaluation is subjective and your acuity would differ from another person’s.
If you are a color sensitive person, you might need to consider a higher color (D-G) to avoid seeing any tinge of yellow in your diamond.
|Carat Size||Recommended Color||Most Affordable Color|
|0.5 carat or less||D – G||H – I|
|0.51 ct – 0.99 ct||D – G||H – I|
|1.00 ct – 1.99 ct||D – G||H|
|2.00 ct or more||D – F||G|
There are a number of people who buy emerald cut diamonds for their classic appeal. If you are someone who loves vintage style jewelry, it is perfectly fine for you to go down to J or even K colors where the diamonds show a warm tint.
I personally find the most attractive length to width ratios to be within a range of 1.30-1.50:1.00. Emeralds with these l/w ratios tend to showcase the flavor of emerald shape better.
In general, the more squarish the shape, the more suitable it is for someone with slender and long fingers. Vice versa, the more rectangular the diamond is, the more suitable it is for someone with short and thick fingers.
That said, I need to stress that the preference for a diamond’s outline is entirely up to an individual’s personal choices. Some people might prefer a more squarish look with a L/W ratio in the range of 1.20:1.00 while some others may like their diamonds slightly elongated.
If you aren’t sure what your preferences are, you may want to review a range of emerald cut diamonds to see how they look like before making a decision.
Compared to round diamonds, the price of emerald cut diamonds are generally 20-30% cheaper and they can give you a bigger bang for your buck. Depending on the qualities of the diamond, the prices can vary according to the 4Cs (carat, cut, color and clarity).
Price chart comparison of GIA certified 1ct emerald diamonds.
Obviously, a diamond with better material quality and specifications will cost more. As you can see from the price chart above, the differences between the higher tier and lower tier grades can be significant!
When buying an engagement ring, most people have a limited amount of budget to work with. One mistake that most beginners make is to assume that a D/IF diamond is going to look better than an eyeclean G/VS2 diamond.
The truth is that differences in color and clarity gradings are subtle and largely technical. Visually, a G/VS2 diamond would look similar to a D/IF in the face up view. This means that if you don’t need a symbolic D/IF clarity, you can save alot of money simply by being practical and buying a diamond with lower color and clarity ratings.
Besides retaining dead weight which makes the diamond look small for its carat weight, an excessive pavilion bulge can also cause problems during the setting process.
Unfortunately, grading reports do not contain any information or details on the presence or degree of pavilion bulging. You need to eyeball the diamond in order to determine that!
However, there are some tell-tale signs you can observe and beware of. An excessive bulge on the pavilion tends to cause windowing and extinction in the diamond’s optical characteristics.
Windowing is usually found in diamonds that are cut too shallow and also manifest when the proportions are all wrong. If you can see through the diamond easily, there is significant windowing and here’s a quick test you can do.
Hold up the loose diamond with a tweezer. With the other hand, run your finger underneath the diamond and look through it. If you can easily make out the fleshy colors of your finger, this means there is a huge amount of light leakage through the diamond.
Extinction, on the other hand, refers to the presence of dark areas within the diamond. They are typically found in stones that are cut to high depth percentages and can also occur due to the rounding of the pavilion facets caused by the excessive bulge.
Such diamonds are best avoided for their extreme extinction (left) and windowing (right) effects.
As you can see, there is a high degree of uncertainty when choosing a diamond solely based on numbers shown in a grading report. You really need videos to help you see and visualize the diamonds.
If a fancy cut diamond deviates too much from its typical proportions, it can look awkward and may cause problems during the jewelry setting process. Ideally, the four corners should be sufficiently large for prongs to secure the stone without being overbearing.
The diamond on the left is a good example of a well proportioned emerald cut while the one on the right isn’t.
Also, you want to double check that the facet edges are neat and parallel to each other from a face-up position. Usually, these variations in symmetry are pronounced and can cause the diamond to detract from their usual look.
Serious symmetry flaws like these should be avoided as they affect contrast patterning.
In this segment, I want to share with you some of my favorite designs to give you an idea of what’s available in the market. Here, I want to point out that the choice of setting design is largely subjective and up to your individual tastes.
In my opinion, a simple four prong setting is one of the best (and no frills) design that showcases the unique step cut patterning of the emerald cut. If you are clueless about what to get, solitaire four prong rings are evergreen designs that you can’t go wrong with.
For fans of vintage style designs, I recommend a 3 stone setting with side baguettes that gives off a classy and timeless appearance. The tapered baguette sidestones also help to accentuate the center stone by drawing your eyes towards it.
Due to their rectangularish geometric shapes, you don’t usually see pave or halo ring settings designed for emerald cut diamonds. For people who want to make a bold fashion statement and are more adventurous in their choice of designs, these are 2 unique designs that might appeal to you.
With clever use of thin shanks and cathedral designs, the size of the emerald cut diamond can be made to look larger than it is. Here are 2 designs that I like and they are very affordable for people on a tight budget.
To recap, here are my recommended guidelines for buying an emerald shape diamond:
Depth: 61% to 68%
Table: 60% to 65%
Polish/Symmetry: Very Good or Excellent
Length to Width Ratio: Within a range of 1.30 to 1.50
Color: G or better
Clarity: VS2 or better
The table of ideal proportions should serve as a tool to help you quickly weed out lousy diamonds. The point to bear in mind is that you should always utilize videos to help you assess the cut quality and appearance of the diamond.
As I stated earlier, you need to go online to shop for emerald cut diamonds because physical retailers do not have the inventory for you to cherry pick from. Get this, the majority of the diamonds in the market are poorly cut and a physical retailer would probably only have 2-3 diamonds because of the high stocking costs.
I had to scour more than 500 diamonds just to pick out 4 great stones. What do you think your odds are at a physical jeweler who probably has little knowledge of cut quality and a mediocre selection of diamonds for you to choose from?
With emerald shape diamonds, the best places to buy your engagement ring would be Blue Nile and James Allen. All 3 are highly reputable and offer HD video listings. Also, they have excellent risk-free sales policies and have a large selection of GIA certified diamonds for you to choose from.
With that, I hope you enjoyed the article and found it useful. If you have any questions or need my help to pick out a diamond, simply contact me via email or leave a comment below.