Demystifying the Cut Grade in a Diamond Certificate

diamond cut grading in reports

1 Carat Round

Contrary to common belief, cut does not refer to shape of the diamond – oval, pear, round, etc. Instead, the cut of a diamond is comprised of components like polish, symmetry and proportions.

Now, the cut of a diamond has the largest bearing on its physical appearance which affects its fire, brilliance and scintillation (contrast patterning). That is why I always emphasize on getting the best cut possible when you are selecting a diamond.

A well cut diamond will exhibit a great balance of these attributes and look breathtaking. In contrast, a poorly cut diamond will resemble frozen spit and look dull.

  

Did You Know That...

  

The Ugly Truth – 90% of the World’s Diamonds Are Cut Poorly

When a cutter is fashioning a diamond from a rough stone, he endeavors to strike a balance between “optimal” cut (which eventually determines appearance) and maximum yield (preserving carat weight from rough stone).

However, the fact that people are willing to pay more for a bigger poorly cut diamond than a smaller well cut diamond puts a lot of pressure on the cutter to preserve weight from the rough stone. Since the value of a diamond is directly proportional to its weight, cut quality is usually compromised for carat weight.

This is the reason why the majority of diamonds are often cut to poor proportions. It is also why you often see diamonds with precise carat weights at 0.70 or 1.00 carat instead of 0.67 or 0.96 since they sell for more!

In today’s market, there are many gemological labs that provide diamond grading services for the industry. However, each lab has a slightly different way of representing the cut grade in a report. For the purpose helping you understand things better, we are going to explain how cut is represented by 4 of the most well-known labs.

GIA – The World’s Foremost Authority in Gem Grading

GIA Diamond Grading Report – From January 2006, GIA started to include the cut grading of round brilliants in their reports. This cut grade (on a scale of excellent to poor) is assigned based on a combined assessment of the diamond’s proportions, polish and symmetry.

2 types of GIA report with cut grading

American Gem Society – Taking Cut Grading to a Higher Level

AGS Diamond Quality Document – AGS was the first independent grading organization to utilize a numerical system in their reports – with 0 being the highest grade. As a diamond deviates further from having ideal light performance, so does the numerical grading value as it starts increasing from 1(Excellent), 2 (Very Good), through to 10 (Poor).

ags platinum light performance quality documents

In the AGS report, the following aspects of a diamond’s cut are evaluated: Crown and Pavilion Angle, Pavilion Depth, Girdle Thickness, Table Diameter, Polish, Culet size, Performance, and Symmetry.

Compared to other labs, the AGS cut grading system follows a more scientific approach which provides better objectivity when assessing a diamond’s cut grade. More notably, they subject the diamond to a comprehensive ray tracing analysis and also evaluate the diamond’s light return with the ASET.

International Gemological Institute – Popular in Europe And Asia

IGI Diamond Report – This report contains similar information found in a GIA report but doesn’t include a proportions diagram. The IGI report provides proportion measurements of the diamond in a numerical format and assigns cut grades within a range of Ideal, Excellent, Very Good, Good and Fair.

The five criteria that IGI primarily use for grading a diamond’s cut are: Total Depth, Girdle Thickness, Pavilion Depth, Crown Angle, and Table Width.

igi reports

Note: IGI grading reports can come in various formats depending on the request.

European Gemological Laboratory – The Jeweler’s Marketing Tool

EGL Report – If you are a consumer intending to make a purchase, stay away from diamonds graded by EGL. EGL is notoriously known for their leniency and lax grading standards.

If you had done some research, you probably found that EGL diamonds are usually priced lower than diamonds graded by other labs like GIA and AGS. However, this does not mean you are getting a good deal.

The truth is, the lower price is reflective of the lower quality diamond it really is. When looking at an EGL report, you can expect to discount 2-3 grades in the diamond’s color and clarity instead of taking the EGL report at face-value.

egl grading reports

For round brilliants, EGL USA offers the Diamond Analysis Report and issues cut grades within the range of: Ideal Plus – Ideal – Very Good – Good – Fair.

Should You Buy Based Solely on What the Report Says?

comparing gemological labsAt this point, I want to go on the record saying that you should only consider buying diamonds graded by GIA or AGS. They are the most consistent labs in terms of their grading standards and offers assurance that the diamond’s qualities have been accurately described.

Next, bear in mind that a diamond’s cut grade is a key factor for consideration when you are making selections. Also, you should note that the lab report isn’t an end all be all solution for selecting the best possible stone.

You see, the grading labs allow diamonds within a range of proportions to fall within their top tier cut category. However, just because a diamond’s proportions fall within “ideal” ranges, it doesn’t mean that the facets interact together as a whole to give the stone optimal light performance.

In order to help you determine this, the easiest method is to use light performance scopes like the ASET and Idealscope for assessment. To find out more, we had dedicated an entire section of the website showing you how to pick a diamond here.

Lastly, I want to share an interesting story with you before I end this article. In a recent trade show I attended, I had the opportunity to speak to people in the management levels from various labs such as EGL, GIA and AGS. I asked them the following question. “Would you buy a diamond graded by your own lab based on a certificate alone assuming that it has the best possible ratings in all aspects of cut?”

The answers were all unanimously: No. Mind you, these are all experts in the field and not some unknown John Doe. All of them stated that they either need to look at the diamond in person or required further data before they would commit to a purchase.

The moral of the story here is – you do require additional data beyond a grading report if you want to make rational buying decisions!

If you are looking for ideally cut diamonds, I recommend checking out James Allen, Whiteflash and Brian Gavin. Besides providing you with magnified photographs/videos of the actual diamonds, they also provide technical data like the ASET and Idealscope images to help you evaluate a diamond’s cut.

Related Articles

Share This Page on Social Media!

9 Comments

  1. Catherine-
    October 2, 2016 at 12:02 am

    Hello! Not sure if you had replied to my other comment on here since I can’t find my comment. Was just wondering what you think of Vera Wang engagement rings? Excellent website by the way! Thank you! :)

  2. Paul Gian-
    October 3, 2016 at 4:09 am

    I did reply to that comment about Vera Wang rings. It’s on this page: https://beyond4cs.com/2016/07/differences-between-10k-14k-18k-yellow-gold-karat/

    You will need to scroll all the way down to see it.

  3. Craig-
    November 28, 2016 at 10:33 pm

    Hi Paul,

    You seem to provide great, unbiased information on your site so I have a question as someone very new to diamond shopping.

    I recently purchased an ideal cut cushion modified brilliant diamond from a trusted online retailer as the center stone of an engagement ring. Long story short my fiancé decided to change the setting to something different a few months afterwards. Upon getting the new final engagement ring we received our new appraisal. This jeweler classified the center stone’s cut at Fair-Good and provided numerous specifications as to why he graded it this way which after I researched seemed to be correct. Is the cut grade on this type of stone subjective? Should I contact the retailer who sold me the diamond and ask about their grading methods? Thanks!

  4. Paul Gian-
    November 29, 2016 at 2:26 am

    There’s no recognized cut grading for fancy shapes like cut grading except those offered by AGS. So, take whatever claims your vendor says about the diamond being “ideal” with a pinch of salt. I would use an ASET to determine light performance myself instead of relying on someone else to claim what it is.

  5. Jacquard C.-
    December 9, 2016 at 2:02 am

    Hello, Paul.

    First of all: thank you for your advice and information you wrote. It is really helpful, as many people like me are generally not accustomed to know about diamonds nor rings, and then we need to sudenly spend a good amount of money on them.

    I wanted to know if you could please tell me your opinion on this engagement ring for my girfriend. I went to a jewelry and tried to apply what I learnt here (for instance, important of cut):

    It is a 14k white gold, round center 3-stone ring mounting with 2 sapphires and a diamond.

    -Diamond: .32 CT. Cut: Very good. Color: I. Clarity: VS2.
    -Sapphires: Two loose sapphires (no info about them. I know they cost 80 US$ each).

    After reducing the price several times (several minutes of tug of war – I am a student, so they tried to help me very kindly): they offered me all of that for 1000 US$. They said it is a very good deal. They were very nice to me and helpful.

    I think they graded everything by themselves, so maybe a VG cut might be a Good cut for other people.

    Thank you very much!

  6. Paul Gian-
    December 9, 2016 at 4:14 am

    For small purchases, most diamonds don’t get graded by a 3rd party lab. You can actually size them up and ask them to show you diamonds that are graded by GIA as a triple excellent and compare them against the ring you are interested in. This will give you an idea of what you are buying.

  7. Jacquard C.-
    December 9, 2016 at 4:57 am

    Ok. It makes sense it works that way. Thank you.
    By the way: could you please tell me about whether it is a good price what I mentioned before?

    Thank you

  8. Jenny-
    April 13, 2017 at 3:17 am

    Hi Paul,
    Thank you so much for the imformative page! Has helped me educate my self somewhat on picking my perfect ring.
    If you have a minute could you please check these diamonds out and give me your opinion on these. I ideally would like a 1.80 for under 11,500, but dont think that is gong to happen with a great cut. Or if you have any other suggestion I would really appreciate it. Diamond would be on a pave band.
    Thank you for your time.
    Jenny

  9. Paul Gian-
    April 13, 2017 at 8:56 am

    The link doesn’t work for me. Only the person who logged into the BlueNile account can see the diamond comparison. It would be best to copy and paste the direct url links of the diamonds you are looking at or email me in private.

Leave A Comment