The Best Engagement Rings Under $5000 (Make Her Say Yes!)

proposing with wedding ring costing five thousand dollars

Conventional wisdom dictates that a guy should spend 2-3 months’ salary on an engagement ring. And if you go by the guidelines, the cost of  a diamond ring can go as high as $10,000 to $20,000 depending on your income.

However, you don’t have to break the bank in order to buy a breathtaking diamond ring nor do you have to follow the rules established by jewelers that make you spend more.

In today’s article, we will showcase some of the very best engagement rings for under $5000 (in our opinion). We will also reveal insider tips to shopping smart and help you get best bang for your buck…

Popular Designs For Engagement Rings Under $5000

With a budget of five thousand dollars, you can explore a variety of designs and still get a good quality engagement ring. Below, we’ve rounded up 10 of the prettiest engagement rings with a variety of different metals, diamond sizes and shapes.

Scroll down to check them out and feel free to click on the images to see full details!

#1 – Floating Halo Diamond Engagement Ring

An elegant setting created by Blue Nile, this platinum setting flaunts a halo that accentuates the size of the center stone. The micropave diamonds on the shanks add another dimension of sparkle to the ring too.

floating halo diamond ring around $5000

FYI, I’ve recently purchased this ring design from Blue Nile. I’ve also written an indepth review of the ring’s craftsmanship and appearance. If you are interested to see close up pictures and learn about the entire shopping process, click this link

#2 – Tiffany Inspired 6 Prong Solitaire Ring With 0.90 ct Round Diamond

This knife edge solitaire ring design combines an evergreen design with low pricing. At the time of writing, the 6 prong setting costs only $240 and offers superb value for money. Simple, classy and affordable!

best engagement rings under 5000 solitaire

#3 – Floral Halo Diamond Engagement Ring For Less Than 5K

This dainty ring has a 0.84ct H color internally flawless round diamond that is surrounded by a floral motif. When seen from a distance, it resembles a bouquet of flowers on your finger and is bound to attract compliments from people.

5 000 engagement ring in flower design

#4 – Heart Shaped Halo Engagement Ring in 14k Rose Gold

This gorgeous ring boosts a lovely heart shape halo that encircles a 0.82 carat diamond. Besides adding sparkle to the ring, the halo also serves to highlight the outline of the center stone and accentuates its shape appeal.

heart shaped engagement rings 5000

#5 – Petite Vintage Pavé Leaf Diamond Engagement Ring

A fusion of nature and vintage inspiration, this alluring ring features a 1 carat Asscher cut diamond that is held securely with 4 prongs. The intertwining leaf design on the shank is finished with a lovely milgrain edge.

vintage 5000 dollar engagement ring with asscher cut

#6 – Hand-Engraved Micropavé Diamond Engagement Ring For $5000

This 14k white gold ring takes inspiration from the vintage era and showcases a hand engraved motif. On the sides of the ring are pave melee diamonds that add a layer of brilliance and sparkle. The detailing on this ring is fantastic as well and you can see the expertly handmade milgrain edges.

5k wedding ring engraved motifs

#7 – Petite Solitaire Engagement Ring With 1ct Marquise Diamond

Sometimes less is more. This petite solitaire design from Blue Nile utilizes a beautiful frame to secure the center diamond. In this manner, the basket enables the diamond to capture light effectively from the surroundings.

marquise diamond engagement rings 5000 dollars

#8 – Three -Stone Ring With 0.80 Ct Diamond And Baguette Sidestones

One of the most popular multi-stone ring designs in today’s market, this classic 3-stone ring design features baguette sidestones on the shanks and carries symbolic meaning. The wire basket is custom made to fit the center stone and secured with ball prongs.

5 thousand dollar wedding ring with baguette sidestones

#9 – Petite Pave Crown Princess Cut Diamond Ring in Platinum

This demure ring features pave melees both the prongs and basket to create a 360° array of sparkle. To add even more bling, the center stone is also accented with diamonds on the shanks for a display of fireworks!

what kind of engagement ring can i get for 5000

#10 – Blue Nile Studio Emerald Vintage Fleur de Lis Halo Engagement Ring

This spectacular halo engagement ring features an emerald cut diamond that is surrounded by 20 round melees. The highlights of the ring are the hand-carved Fleur de Lis motifs and this is topped off with milgrain accents for the center stone.

5k engagement ring halo engagement ring

Besides these awe-inspiring rings, both James Allen and Blue Nile offer hundreds of beautifully made ring designs for you to choose from. Start browsing today and build your perfect ring with high quality diamonds graded by GIA and AGS.

Insider Tips to Shopping Smart And Getting Better Quality

Having been in the industry for years, let me tell you that one of the biggest mistakes consumers make is to buy a preset or off-the-rack diamond ring. While doing so may seem “convenient”, it usually results in a compromise on quality and selection.

On top of that, there is an obscurity in prices since the cost of different components of ring have been “bundled” together. Factors like these enable unethical jewelers to overcharge or push subpar goods from their inventory.

The bottomline is, you should avoid preset engagement rings or “ready-to-ship” options. Instead, you should ONLY be looking at building your own ring based on a loose diamond selection and setting of your choice.

And don’t worry, it is actually a pretty straightforward and fun process. So, if you have a budget of $5,000 for an engagement ring, let me show you the smart way for shopping.

love for dollars money survey

First of all, you need to determine exactly what you want and figure out your recipient’s preferences. These questions should help you piece things together…

  1. Is there anything that your recipient specifically wants?
  2. What type of diamond shape/color/clarity/size do you intend to get?
  3. Do you have a realistic budget for the purchase?
  4. Do you have any leeway to spend more than $5,000 for the diamond ring?
  5. What kind of setting do you have in mind?
  6. Is there any special symbolism that you require for the ring? e.g. D/IF

For people who are absolutely clueless, James Allen and Blue Nile are great places to perform some casual research. With a quick browse, you can quickly get an idea of what’s available and how much the setting/diamond would cost individually.

Balancing the Cost of the Center Stone and Setting Design With $5,000

Let’s face it, most of us have a limited budget to work with. Determining ring specifications before hitting the stores will prevent you from wasting time running around in circles and save you a lot of frustration. More importantly, it also helps you avoid unnecessary upsells and keeps you focused on the task at hand.

If your recipient wants a Tiffany inspired solitaire ring setting, this knowledge will enable you to work backwards and calculate how much of your budget would be left for the center stone. Let me illustrate this by using one of the best 6 prong solitaire setting from White Flash that costs $1,600.

tiffany solitaire ring design budget 5000

The Vatche U-113 is the best Tiffany style ring design in the market.

With a budget of $5,000 for the engagement ring, it leaves you $3,400 ($5000 – $1600) for the center stone. With some simple math, you know exactly how much you can spend on the center stone and this helps you narrow down the available options immediately.

diamonds under 3500

Simply by using search filters, you can instantly narrow down diamond choices for cherry picking.

On the other hand, if you found out that your recipient expects a 1 carat diamond for the proposal ring, then your priority in budget allocation would be geared towards the center stone. In this case, the leftover balance from your budget would go towards the setting.

To illustrate this, let’s say you shortlisted the following 1ct princess cut diamond from James Allen which costs $4,140. With a budget of $5,000, this would leave a balance of $860 ($5,000 – $4,140) for the setting.

1 carat princess cut diamond 4000 dollars

With this information in hand, you can now narrow down the available setting designs that costs around $860. See screenshot below…

james allen wedding rings for five thousand dollars

Contrary to what some people may think, building your own ring on a five thousand dollars budget is pretty straightforward and well worth the effort. Not only does it allow you to cherry pick the best diamonds, it is also an enjoyable experience to handpick the ring for a loved one.

Summary – A $5000 Budget is More Than Enough For a Beautiful Ring

As you can see, the perfect engagement ring doesn’t have to cost a fortune. If you shop smart and approach the purchase with a practical mindset, it is possible to buy a stunning ring for under $5,000.

Remember to think of her personal style and preferences before deciding what to buy. And as a reminder, sometimes less is better. The key is to strike a balance between your budget and expectations.

Good luck with the ring shopping and if you have any questions or need help with a selection, feel free to drop me an email or leave a comment below!

Unlike brick and mortar stores, online retailers like James Allen, Blue Nile and White Flash are the best places to shop for engagement rings because they provide complete transparency in their listings. On top of that, you get to choose the best stones and enjoy competitive prices!

Related Articles

Share This Page on Social Media!

14 Comments

  1. Vilma Arvidsson-
    March 12, 2017 at 12:01 pm

    I am looking for Tiffany engagement rings under 5000 and found a couple of sellers on eBay who are offering authentic rings on the secondary market cheaply. Can you help me take a look and offer some comments?

  2. Paul Gian-
    March 13, 2017 at 4:26 pm

    For a 5000 engagement ring budget, my advice is to look at non-branded goods so that you can stretch your dollars. Buying on eBay opens you up to alot of scammers who prey on unsuspecting consumers because they think they are getting a cheap deal. When a listing says a “genuine” Tiffany ring is on offer, let me tell you that this is a blatant misrepresentation in most cases. If you want to buy a branded piece, go straight to the original store and pay the premium. That’s a better way to do things.

  3. Riccardo Longo-
    July 1, 2017 at 10:43 pm

    I want to thank you for all the hard work placed into your website and for doing a blog post on the best engagement rings under 5000. If I want to save money and get a bigger carat diamond, is it true that fancy shapes are cheaper than rounds?

  4. Paul Gian-
    July 2, 2017 at 1:54 am

    You are right about the observation that fancy shapes cost less per carat if you do the calculations. Rounds are more expensive for a reason and that’s because they use up more rough material compared to other shapes. As I mentioned in my other posts, another method to bring down the cost is to go lower in color and clarity.

  5. Damgaard-
    August 23, 2017 at 1:07 pm

    Would you have any idea what kind of engagement ring can I get for 5000 if I walk into Cartier? My girlfriend loves the brand but I am apprehensive of the high prices there.

  6. Paul Gian-
    August 23, 2017 at 10:35 pm

    For 5k, you can probably get a 0.5ct diamond ring from Cartier. You need to understand that there is a huge brand premium on their prices. I actually helped a friend shop at Cartier and he fully understands that he can get a similar ring for half the price they charge. This write up here contains a detailed experience of the purchase:

    http://beyond4cs.com/reviews/cartier/

    For a 5000 engagement ring budget, you can easily get a 0.7 to 0.8 carat diamond ring with better quality elsewhere.

  7. Monica-
    November 23, 2017 at 6:19 am

    Currently, we are working with a jeweler for an engagement ring around 5000. They offered us an EGL diamond with J color/SI1 clarity for less than $3000. The setting is very similar to the 3 stone baguette ring in your post but he is using trilliant sidestones instead. Would you be able to help me assess the quality of the diamond if I sent you the EGL certificate?

  8. Paul Gian-
    November 24, 2017 at 9:42 am

    EGL diamonds are a scam and a blatant rip off to misrepresent the goods that are sold. I can guarantee you that this diamond be significantly worse than J SI1 if the same stone was graded by a reliable lab like GIA. Let me tell you that the 5k engagement ring you intend to commission with this jeweler will not be worth it and you actually end up paying more!

  9. Monica-
    November 27, 2017 at 12:01 pm

    The jeweler told us that EGL is as good as GIA and that the certificate is just a piece of paper. We’ve seen the stone in person and it looks lovely. But we are having second doubts now that you warned us of it.

  10. Paul Gian-
    November 28, 2017 at 11:42 pm

    Just do a quick Google search on EGL scams or EGL lawsuits. You will find plenty of examples on why the laboratory eventually closed doors after getting banned from the industry’s trading network

  11. Marylee-
    February 2, 2018 at 6:55 pm

    You mentioned that we should avoid premade rings. What do you think of the preset diamond rings from James Allen and Blue Nile?

  12. Paul Gian-
    February 4, 2018 at 11:01 pm

    Most preset engagement rings are mounted using diamonds with mediocre cut quality. This applies to BOTH online and offline retailers. Even though I am a proponent for online shopping, I would not recommend buying pre-set rings from either company.

    For people who are “lazy” or simply can’t be bothered to put in the extra effort, you will likely end up with a mediocre ring or overpay for inferior quality. Do a little reading up on Beyond4cs.com and you should be able to create your own ring with better quality.

  13. Joe Gardner-
    March 7, 2018 at 6:15 am

    Great information! I have some unanswered questions. I am looking at cushion cut engagement rings under 5000 from some of the vendors you listed above. I need the ring urgently for an upcoming proposal next week. What do you think of these diamonds?

    https://www.jamesallen.com/loose-diamonds/cushion-cut/1.01-carat-h-color-si1-clarity-sku-3036002

    https://www.jamesallen.com/loose-diamonds/cushion-cut/1.03-carat-h-color-si1-clarity-sku-3532232

    https://www.jamesallen.com/loose-diamonds/cushion-cut/1.00-carat-g-color-si1-clarity-sku-3137367

    Any help you can offer would be appreciated.

  14. Paul Gian-
    March 7, 2018 at 9:44 am

    Ditch option #1 and #2. They are either not eyeclean or not well cut. The 3rd stone is a great choice as it has strong light return and well dispersed inclusions. Go for that!

Leave A Comment